(412) 263-3016

2300 Smallman St
Pittsburgh, PA 15219 40.4536 -79.9818

Get Map & Directions »

Neighborhood: Strip District

BENKOVITZSEAFOODS.…

Reviews & Ratings for Benkovitz Seafoods

4 Star Rating: Recommended

5 reviews

What users are saying:

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

04/06/09

AWESOME

by CSMobileUser

Awesome

  • Pros: Example: best croissants in town
  • Cons: What are the drawbacks?
1 Star Rating: Poor

04/02/08

How the mighty fish sandwich hath fallen

by Gary34

First time message:

I just returned to the "burgh after an 10 year absence and headed straight for Benkovitz. The fried fish in a dish was cooked in dark brown fat that should have been thrown away days ago, had a thick mystery coating and was burnt. The other order, smelts, was cooked the same way but in addition, the smelts were so fishy tasting that they were inedible. Like so many things, the memory was better than the experience.

The grease soaked through the plastic boxes and bags.

Yuk!

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

09/25/05

Best in the city!

by danny9494

For fresh fish, this is the best in the city. I've bought many different kinds of fresh fish here as well as their salads, and have always been more than satisfied. Isn't even any "fishy" smell in the place...

I'm a huge fish sandwich fan too and this is still the best in the city that I've had.

Gets crowded around lunch and the holidays, so watch out for that.

  • Pros: Inexpensive, Great service
4 Star Rating: Recommended

08/18/03

This Strip District fish house is known for their fresh, high-quality seafood throughout the region.

by Contributor

The Scene
There are no indoor tables; the lunch crowd stands elbow-to-elbow at long counters, sharing condiments and making small talk between big bites. Outdoor tables number about five on nice days.

The Food
In the retail area of their large warehouse, they have a fresh-cooked seafood counter. Their specialty is the fried fish sandwich, but they also offer a decent broiled variety. Ingredients are top-notch and couldn't be fresher. Customers can also pick up fried shrimp, fish hoagies and grilled swordfish sandwiches.

When to Go
Exceptionally popular for lunch, the line around noon can be long. Try to get there early or late. And watch out during Lent.

4.5 Star Rating: Recommended

06/02/03

Best Seafood for sale in pittsburgh

by ldgazaroth

I'm originally from the Boston area, so my standards for fresh seafood (especially shellfish) is extremely. Ive purchased fish from Benkovitz three times, and it has always been excellent. The quality is high, the seafood is extremely fresh, and the staff is very helpful. The price is also very reasonable. The tuna filet I bought last would have gone for $50 at a good restaurant. I paid $15 for it.

I recommend anyone who cooks and loves fresh seafood to check them out. Looks like a restaurant from the outside, but there is a very clean fish market inside. Youll find a selection of whole fish, filets, and steaks as well as a range of shellfish. My only complaint is that their selection can be limited.

  • Pros: Reasonably Priced, Very Fresh, Very Clean
  • Cons: Limited Selection
Advertisement

Best of Citysearch

Things To Do Nearby Benkovitz Seafoods

Recent Reviews In Pittsburgh

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Domino's Pizza

4717 Liberty Ave, Pittsburgh, PA

5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

Star Garden Chinese Restaurant

587 Clairton Blvd, Pittsburgh, PA

1 Star Rating: Poor

De Luca's Restaurant

2015 Penn Ave, Pittsburgh, PA

1 Star Rating: Poor

Aladdin's Eatery

5878 Forbes Ave, Pittsburgh, PA

Advertisement